Can a New Mattress Cause Back Pain?

Key Takeaways

  • Expectation vs. Reality: While many people believe that getting a new mattress should provide instant comfort and support, it’s important to balance these expectations with the reality of an adjustment period. Transitioning to a new mattress can lead to temporary discomfort as your body adapts to the new sleeping surface.
  • Signs Your New Mattress May Be the Cause: It’s essential to pay attention to signs that your new mattress may be causing back pain. These signs include waking up with back pain and stiffness, tossing and turning at night, experiencing pain in new areas, and noticing an increased severity of existing back pain.
  • Choosing the Right Mattress and Accessories: The right mattress and accessories, such as mattress toppers, lumbar supports, and ergonomic pillows, can significantly impact your comfort and back health. Selecting a mattress that aligns with your preferred sleeping position and comfort level is crucial to ensuring a pain-free night’s rest. Additionally, a gradual transition and consistency in sleep routines can aid in adapting to a new mattress.

In searching for a good night’s sleep, the perfect mattress often takes center stage.

We all know the excitement that comes with replacing an old, worn-out mattress with a brand-new one – the promise of enhanced comfort, better support, and a potential remedy for those mornings marred by back pain.

Save $150 On Any Mattress

Plus free shipping

Get $150 OFF Mattresses

But here’s a question: Can getting a new mattress actually make your back hurt? People who care about their health and sleep are wondering about this.

“The relationship between a new mattress and back pain is significant,” says Dr. Jordan Burns. “While ‘The Journal of Sleep Research‘ may not explicitly address this, studies affirm that the right mattress is crucial for spinal health. When transitioning to a new mattress, ensure it provides adequate support to maintain the natural curvature of the spine, as improper alignment can contribute to discomfort.”

Let’s find out if switching to a new mattress can really lead to uncomfortable back pain.

Signs Your New Mattress May Be Causing Back Pain

One of the clearest indicators that a new mattress is causing pain is if you begin experiencing back pain shortly after getting the new bed that you didn’t have before.

Some key signs your mattress may be causing discomfort include:

1. Waking Up With Back Pain and Stiffness

If you notice back pain, achiness, and stiffness in the morning that eases up after you get out of bed and start moving around, this points strongly to the mattress as the culprit.

Discomfort that is worse in the morning but improves once you are up, indicates the bed failed to properly support your back as you slept.

2. Tossing and Turning at Night

If you find yourself tossing and turning much more than usual and feel like you can’t get comfortable in any position, this is a red flag.

The continuous repositioning indicates the mattress is not adapting well to your body and pressure points. This can lead to pain and restless nights as you try fruitlessly to find a pain-free sleeping position.

3. New Areas of Pain in Shoulders, Hips, or Neck

You may notice new specific areas of pain in places like your shoulders, hips, or neck that you didn’t experience before.

This can occur when a mattress pushes against pressure points and doesn’t cushion them well.

These new tender and painful spots suggest your new bed is the culprit.

4. Increased Severity of Existing Back Pain

If you entered your new mattress purchase already dealing with some back pain issues, be on high alert if your existing pain seems significantly worse after switching beds.

Even if your previous mattress wasn’t ideal, a bed that exacerbates ongoing back problems is a major red flag.

5. Improved Pain in Other Beds or Locations

Notice if you feel like you sleep better and have less pain when resting or napping on beds, couches, or locations other than your new mattress.

This is a clear sign your new bed is the root of the problem.

When other surfaces give relief, look directly at the new mattress as the pain culprit.

6. Partner Also Develops Back Pain

Finally, if your sleep partner starts voicing concerns about new or worsening back pain since getting the new mattress, pay close attention.

When two people develop unexplained pain on the same new bed, it’s a strong sign the mattress itself is the issue.

Give 2-3 weeks for your body to adjust to a new mattress before making final judgments.

But if you notice multiple symptoms above, don’t ignore ongoing back pain that indicates a mismatch with your new bed.

What Happens When We Switch To A New Mattress?

Switching to a new mattress might require some settling in time. Here are the different phases you should expect:

1. Navigating the Adjustment Phase

Switching to a new mattress is akin to breaking in a pair of shoes – it requires an adjustment period.

This transition is often called the “break-in” phase, during which your body gets acquainted with the new sleeping surface.

It’s important to manage expectations during this time, understanding that immediate comfort might not be guaranteed.

This phase is not necessarily an indication of the mattress causing lasting discomfort but rather a reflection of your body’s need to adapt.

2. The Body’s Adaptation Process

Our bodies are remarkable in their ability to adapt, but change doesn’t happen overnight.

When introducing a new mattress into the equation, your muscles and ligaments need time to recalibrate to the different levels of support and cushioning.

This adaptation extends beyond just the initial feel – it involves aligning your spine and pressure points according to the mattress’s characteristics.

During this period, you might find yourself experiencing changes in sleep quality, comfort, and, yes, even a temporary twinge of back pain. Research highlights that low sleep quality can cause back pain.

3. Temporary Discomfort During Transition

It’s essential to address the elephant in the room – the possibility of experiencing discomfort during the adjustment period.

As your body adapts to the new mattress, it might manifest as temporary back pain.

This discomfort doesn’t necessarily stem from the mattress being inherently unsuitable but rather from the shift your body is undergoing.

Just as you might experience muscle soreness after starting a new exercise routine, the transition phase can lead to minor discomfort that should gradually dissipate as your body acclimates to the mattress’s unique features.

“Preserving spinal health with a new mattress requires a holistic approach,” says Dr. Burns. “‘The Lancet Neurology’ emphasizes the need for individualized sleep solutions. Regular exercise, proper sleep hygiene, and ergonomic considerations complement the choice of a new mattress. It’s not just about the mattress itself but the overall lifestyle and sleep environment that contribute to a healthy back.”

Reasons for Seeking a New Mattress

Usually, the following reasons trigger people to buy new mattresses:

Wear and Tear: As the years roll by, mattresses age and accumulate subtle signs of wear and tear. That initial softness might transition into noticeable sagging, rendering the once-supportive mattress less effective in providing comfort.

Lifestyle Changes: Major life events like moving into a new home, getting married, or accommodating a growing family often prompt the quest for a new mattress. These changes reflect a desire for a fresh start, and good sleep should be the priority for the new beginnings.

Health and Well-being: Individuals with changing health needs might seek a mattress that addresses specific concerns. This could involve transitioning to a mattress designed for better spinal alignment or improved pressure relief, contributing to an overall sense of comfort.

Research findings underscore the intricate link between mattress quality and back pain,” says Dr. Burns. “A sudden change in the mattress can disrupt sleep patterns and exacerbate existing spinal issues. Opt for a mattress that aligns with your specific needs, considering factors like firmness, material, and individual preferences to mitigate the risk of back pain.”

The Belief in Enhanced Comfort and Support

When buying a new mattress, most of us assume it provides more support and comfort. Have you wondered what’s the logic behind this belief? Here are the reasons:

a. Material Innovation and Expectations

The mattress industry is continuously evolving, introducing innovative materials and advanced technologies to enhance sleep quality.

Memory foam, latex, hybrid constructions – these components promise unparalleled comfort and support, often raising the bar of expectations for a new mattress.

The idea that these modern materials should naturally align with our body contours and relieve pressure points fuels the anticipation of immediate comfort upon laying down.

b. Marketing Messages

Marketing campaigns from mattress companies often emphasize the luxurious comfort and superior support their products offer.

Catchy slogans and vivid visuals of blissful sleepers contribute to the belief that a new mattress is an instant ticket to a pain-free night’s rest.

These messages tend to tap into our desires for relaxation and stress relief, further strengthening the association between a new mattress and comfort.

c. Personal Testimonials

Anecdotes from friends, family, or even online reviews can reinforce the notion that a new mattress equals comfort.

Individuals who have experienced positive results – improved sleep, reduced discomfort – after switching to a new mattress are likely to share their success stories.

These personal accounts, while valuable, contribute to a broader perception that a new mattress should inherently provide comfort and alleviate back pain.

d. Psychological Priming

Investing in a new mattress primes our minds to expect positive outcomes. We anticipate our purchase will lead to better sleep and relief from back pain.

This psychological aspect can play a significant role in our perception of comfort.

However, it’s important to acknowledge that our bodies may need time to adjust to a new sleeping surface, potentially leading to temporary discomfort before experiencing the promised comfort.

e. Balancing Reality With Expectations

While the anticipation of comfort is valid, it’s essential to balance these expectations with the reality of the adjustment period.

A new mattress might indeed offer enhanced support and comfort in the long run, but the immediate transition might come with temporary discomfort as our bodies adapt.

This balance between immediate comfort and the potential for an adjustment period forms a central aspect of our exploration into whether a new mattress can cause back pain.

“Transitioning to a new mattress involves an adjustment period,” says Dr. Burns. “To prevent back pain during this transition, gradually introduce the new mattress by spending shorter durations initially. Pay attention to your body’s response, and consider additional lumbar support if needed. This aligns with the recommendations of the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, emphasizing the importance of personalized sleep solutions.”

Choosing the Right Mattress

Just as we have unique tastes in food and fashion, our sleep preferences are equally distinct.

The significance of choosing the right mattress is in crafting an individualized sleep haven.

Your mattress should cater to your preferred sleeping position, comfort level, and any specific health concerns you might have.

It’s not about what’s universally popular but what’s perfectly tailored to your needs.

1. Firmness Can Be Customized To Sleep Positions

Suppose you select the right mattress for your needs.

In that case, you cannot only reduce the transition time significantly but might reduce the back pain or other discomfort associated with a new mattress.

Based on different sleep positions, here’s the suggestive level of firmness you should look forward to:

Back Sleepers: For those who sleep on their backs, a mattress with medium to firm support is often recommended. This ensures that your spine maintains its natural alignment, preventing excessive sinking and promoting even weight distribution.

Side Sleepers: Side sleepers benefit from a slightly softer mattress that cushions the shoulders and hips. This reduces pressure points and aligns the spine, minimizing the risk of waking up with a sore back.

Stomach Sleepers: Stomach sleepers typically require a mattress on the firmer side to prevent excessive sinking of the torso. This helps maintain a neutral spine position and alleviates stress on the lower back.

2. Mattress Quality and Materials

The quality and composition of mattress materials play a pivotal role in the potential impact on back pain.

Different materials offer varying levels of support, cushioning, and responsiveness, directly affecting how well the mattress aligns with your body’s contours and sleeping preferences.

Memory Foam

Memory foam mattresses are known for their ability to conform closely to the body’s shape. This adaptability can provide excellent pressure relief, ensuring that your spine maintains its natural alignment while you sleep.


Latex mattresses strike a balance between support and responsiveness.

The natural buoyancy of latex provides a gentle pushback, promoting proper spinal alignment regardless of your sleep position.


Innerspring mattresses rely on a system of coils to provide support.

While they can offer excellent firmness and responsiveness, the effectiveness in promoting spinal alignment depends on the coil configuration and the mattress’s overall construction.

Mattress Accessories and Back Pain Alleviation

These accessories can aid in addressing specific comfort needs and mitigating potential back pain triggers.

a. Mattress Toppers

A quality mattress topper can act as a buffer between you and your new mattress, providing extra comfort.

Look for options that offer targeted support – memory foam toppers, for example, can contour to your body’s shape, promoting spinal alignment and pressure relief.

A topper can also help reduce the initial firmness of a new mattress, allowing your body to adjust gradually.

b. Lumbar Supports

Lumbar or lower back supports are designed to maintain the natural curve of your spine, ensuring proper alignment.

Placing a lumbar support pillow beneath your lower back while transitioning to a new mattress can alleviate strain and reduce the risk of developing discomfort. This simple addition can make a significant difference, especially for individuals prone to lower back pain.

c. Ergonomic Pillows

The right pillow complements your mattress, offering comprehensive support for your head and neck.

An ergonomic pillow that aligns your spine in accordance with your sleep position can enhance your comfort as your body adapts to the new mattress.

Remember, your pillow should work in harmony with your mattress to promote optimal alignment and reduce stress on your back.

Tips for a Seamless Transition To a New Mattress

Professionals recommend a gradual approach when transitioning to a new mattress.

Experts advise starting with short sleep on the new mattress and gradually increasing it over a week or two.

This allows your body to adjust without overwhelming it.

Additionally, some suggest using a mattress topper or pad to provide a buffer between your body and the new mattress, aiding the transition process.

Here are a few tips to help you in a seamless transition to a new mattress:

a. Mitigating Potential Back Pain

The path to a pain-free experience with your new mattress begins with patience and thoughtful adjustments.

Gradually introduce your body to the new mattress by starting with a few hours of sleep each night.

This helps prevent sudden changes that could lead to discomfort.

b. Strategic Pillow Support

Supportive pillows play a significant role during the adjustment phase.

Consider using a contour pillow that aligns your head and neck with your spine, promoting proper spinal alignment.

A well-chosen pillow can alleviate strain on your back, enhancing your comfort as you adapt to the new mattress.

c. Consistency is Key

Maintaining a consistent sleep schedule aids in the transition process.

Going to bed and waking up at the same time helps regulate your body’s internal clock, contributing to better sleep quality.

Consistency extends beyond the sleep schedule; maintaining your nightly routines can signal to your body that it’s time to unwind, aiding in a smoother transition.


Can Getting a New Mattress Actually Cause Back Pain?

Transitioning to a new mattress might trigger temporary discomfort as your body adjusts to the change.

How do Factors like Poor Posture Contribute to Back Pain?

Poor posture strains muscles and disrupts spinal alignment, potentially leading to back pain.

What's the Importance of Proper Sleep Posture and Alignment?

Proper sleep posture and alignment help prevent strain on muscles and reduce the risk of back pain.

How can Mattress Firmness Affect Sleep Positions?

Mattress firmness should match sleep positions: firm for back sleepers, softer for side sleepers.

What Role does Mattress Quality Play in Back Pain Prevention?

Quality mattresses with proper support and materials can alleviate back pain triggers.

Can Heat Retention in Mattresses Contribute to Back Pain?

Yes, heat retention can lead to restless sleep and muscle tension, potentially causing back discomfort.

How do Cooling Technologies in Mattresses Enhance Comfort?

Cooling technologies regulate temperature, preventing heat buildup and promoting relaxed sleep.

What Accessories can Help during the Transition to a New Mattress?

Mattress toppers, lumbar supports, and ergonomic pillows can aid in adapting to a new mattress.

What's the Long-Term Benefit of a New Mattress for Back Pain?

A well-chosen mattress can improve sleep quality and reduce back pain over time.

Can Lumbar Supports Alleviate Lower Back Pain During Mattress Transition?

Yes, lumbar supports maintain proper spinal alignment, reducing lower back strain.

How do Mattress Toppers Enhance Comfort during the Transition Phase?

Mattress toppers add an extra layer of cushioning and support, aiding in the adjustment to a new mattress.

What's the Synergy between Temperature Control and Back Pain Relief?

Temperature-regulating mattresses prevent overheating, promote relaxation, and reduce potential back pain triggers.


In pursuing optimal sleep quality and back health, the relationship between a new mattress and potential back pain is complex and intriguing.

While the excitement of a new sleep surface is palpable, it’s essential to approach this transition with awareness and understanding.

A nuanced picture emerges as we’ve explored the multifaceted factors at play, from mattress materials and quality to temperature regulation and accessory choices.

Remember, the initial discomfort that might arise during the adjustment phase is a testament to your body’s remarkable adaptability. Once this phase is over, you can enjoy a restful sleep.

This article is for informational purposes and should not replace advice from your doctor or other medical professional.

Sarah Anderson, Certified Sleep Science Coach Sarah Anderson

Sarah Anderson is a sleep, health, and wellness writer and product reviewer. She has written articles on changing and improving your sleep schedule, choosing the right mattress for chronic pain conditions, and finding the best pillow for you. Sarah Anderson has her Bachelor of Arts degree from Arizona State University in Journalism and Mass Communications. Prior to working for Zoma, she wrote for a variety of news publications. Sarah's work has been featured on Bustle, PureWow, and other publications.

View all posts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We think you’ll also enjoy…

Go to top